Understanding the History of Retiree Benefits and the NCBAA Trust Fund
About a 10-minute read
For many retired CATCA members, the differences in benefits available to retirees depending on when they retired have become a source of understandable frustration.
One particularly significant difference is dental coverage. Retirees who left NAV CANADA before January 1, 2010, do not have dental coverage, while eligible retirees who left after that date gained access to dental benefits through the NCBAA Trust Fund in 2023.
We recognize that this difference raises legitimate questions about fairness, how these arrangements developed, and the role CATCA has played.
To help answer those questions, it is important to understand the history of the NCBAA Trust Fund and the agreements that shaped retiree benefits over the past two decades.
Key milestones
2005
NCBAA Trust Fund established (September 1) following the NCJC Benefits Review agreement.
2007
Transfer agreement signed; initial $5.25 million received.
2009
NCJC Benefits Agreement adds $30.5 million and changes funding for future retirees.
2017
Original end date for premium subsidies to pre-2010 retirees — support continues.
2021
Benefits review completed: higher dispensing-fee reimbursement, $450,000 a year in added funding (2021–2023).
2023
Dental benefits introduced for eligible post-2009 retirees.
2025
Ellement becomes plan administrator (April 1).
The Establishment of the Trust Fund: 2005–2007
The NAV CANADA Bargaining Agents Association (NCBAA) Trust Fund was established on September 1, 2005, following an agreement reached between NAV CANADA and the NCBAA on January 13, 2005, during the National Joint Council (NCJC) Benefits Review.
The Trust was created to help eligible retirees and their dependants with the cost of post-retirement benefits.
An initial $5.25 million was identified for transfer to the Trust from surplus and premium-margin accounts associated with Life Insurance Policy 139100. The transfer agreement was signed on June 28, 2007, and the funds were received.
The original intention was for these funds to subsidize retiree benefits until August 31, 2017. However, favourable fund performance has allowed the Trust to continue providing assistance well beyond that date.
A Major Turning Point: The 2009 Benefits Agreement
One of the most significant developments in the Trust's history occurred with the 2009 NCJC Benefits Agreement.
Under that agreement, an additional $30.5 million was provided to the Trust, substantially strengthening its financial foundation.
The agreement also fundamentally changed the structure of post-retirement health-care benefits.
For employees retiring after December 31, 2009, NAV CANADA would no longer contribute directly toward their retiree health-care premiums. Instead, the Trust would become responsible for determining what financial assistance could be provided.
The agreement established different arrangements for employees who had already retired and those who would retire in the future.
| Retirement date | NAV CANADA | NCBAA Trust | Retiree |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sept. 1, 2005 – Aug. 31, 2008 | 60% | 20% | 20% |
| Sept. 1, 2008 – Dec. 31, 2009 | 60% | 15% | 25% |
| Jan. 1, 2010 onward | 0% | 60% | 40% |
For retirees who left between September 1, 2005, and December 31, 2009, NAV CANADA continued to contribute 60% of their health-care premiums, with the remaining costs shared between the Trust and the retiree.
For those retiring after December 31, 2009, NAV CANADA no longer contributed toward retiree health-care premiums. The Trust assumed responsibility for subsidizing 60% of those premiums, with retirees paying the remaining 40%.
These arrangements created distinct groups of retirees with different sources of funding and different obligations under the applicable agreements.
The distinction would become particularly important as the Trust's benefit offerings evolved.
Separate Benefit Plans and Administration
An important distinction between the two retiree groups is that they are covered under separate Sun Life insurance contracts.
Retirees who left NAV CANADA before January 1, 2010, remain covered under a Sun Life contract administered by NAV CANADA. NAV CANADA is responsible for the administration of that plan and decisions concerning its benefit provisions. Neither CATCA nor the NCBAA Trust Fund has access to or decision-making authority over that contract.
Retirees who left after December 31, 2009, are covered under a separate Sun Life contract administered through the NCBAA Trust Fund. The trustees oversee the benefit provisions and administration of this plan, subject to the Trust Agreement and the financial resources available.
Two retiree groups at a glance
Retired before Jan. 1, 2010
- Sun Life contract administered by
- NAV CANADA
- Health-care premiums
- NAV CANADA pays 60%; the Trust and the retiree share the rest
- Dental coverage
- Not included
Retired after Dec. 31, 2009
- Sun Life contract administered by
- NCBAA Trust Fund
- Health-care premiums
- The Trust pays 60%; the retiree pays 40%
- Dental coverage
- Included since 2023
This distinction is particularly important when considering dental coverage. The Trust was able to introduce dental benefits for post-2009 retirees because it administers their benefit plan and had the financial capacity to absorb the additional costs.
Pre-2010 retirees, however, remain covered under the separate NAV CANADA-administered plan. The NCBAA trustees do not have the authority to amend that contract or determine the benefits NAV CANADA provides.
While the Trust continues to contribute toward health-care premiums for pre-2010 retirees, that financial support does not give it control over the benefits provided under NAV CANADA's contract.
Continued Support Beyond 2017
When the Trust was originally established, its commitment to subsidize health-care premiums for pre-2010 retirees was intended to end on August 31, 2017.
However, favourable fund performance allowed the trustees to continue providing that financial assistance beyond the original expiry date.
As a result, pre-2010 retirees have continued to benefit from Trust contributions toward their health-care premiums for more than nine years beyond the originally anticipated funding period.
This continued assistance has helped reduce the cost of health-care coverage for these retirees while maintaining the Trust's broader responsibilities to eligible beneficiaries.
The Introduction of Dental Benefits in 2023
In 2023, the NCBAA Trust Fund introduced dental benefits for eligible retirees who had retired after December 31, 2009.
This improvement was made possible because the Trust's financial position allowed it to absorb the additional cost of providing dental coverage to this group while continuing to meet its existing obligations.
However, retirees who left NAV CANADA before January 1, 2010, were not included in the new dental coverage.
The distinction reflects both the different funding arrangements established through the 2009 Benefits Agreement and the fact that the two groups are covered under separate Sun Life contracts.
Under the 2009 agreement, NAV CANADA retained responsibility for contributing 60% of health-care premiums for pre-2010 retirees, while the Trust assumed a substantially greater funding responsibility for those retiring after 2009, supported by the additional $30.5 million provided under the agreement.
When the Trust's financial position permitted the introduction of dental benefits in 2023, those benefits were made available under the Trust-administered plan covering post-2009 retirees.
The Trust does not administer the separate NAV CANADA plan covering pre-2010 retirees and cannot independently change the benefits available under that contract.
Meanwhile, the Trust has continued to subsidize health-care premiums for pre-2010 retirees, despite the original commitment having expired in 2017.
The result is that the Trust has continued supporting both groups, but in different ways and under different funding and administrative arrangements.
We recognize that this explanation does not eliminate the frustration felt by pre-2010 retirees. These members do not have dental coverage through either NAV CANADA or the NCBAA Trust Fund, while colleagues who retired after 2009 have access to that benefit.
For members who may have worked alongside one another for decades, this difference is understandably difficult to accept.
Other Developments: 2015–2023
The Trust has also evolved through subsequent benefit reviews and funding arrangements.
The NCJC benefits review covering 2015–2021 was completed in 2021. Among the changes was an increase in the eligible prescription dispensing fee reimbursement from $4 to $10, subject to a maximum of five dispensing-fee reimbursements per year for each Drug Identification Number (DIN).
The review also resulted in additional funding for the Trust of $450,000 annually from 2021 through 2023.
These contributions provided additional financial support for the Trust's continuing benefit obligations.
Modernizing Plan Administration: 2024–2025
As the Trust matured, attention also turned to ensuring that its administration continued to meet the needs of retirees.
In 2024, the trustees initiated a formal Request for Proposals process to review the administration of the benefits plan.
Following that process, Ellement replaced Coughlin and Associates as the plan administrator, effective April 1, 2025.
The transition was part of the trustees' ongoing responsibility to oversee the administration of the Trust and ensure appropriate services are provided to eligible retirees and their dependants.
How the Trust Is Governed
The NCBAA Trust Fund is a legally established trust dedicated to providing benefits to eligible retirees and their dependants.
Although its origins lie in negotiated agreements between NAV CANADA and the bargaining agents, the Trust operates under its own governing documents.
The Trust's assets do not belong to NAV CANADA, CATCA, the NCBAA, or individual retirees. They must be managed in accordance with the Trust Agreement and applicable requirements.
Trustees are elected through the NCBAA and are responsible for overseeing the Trust's administration, investment policies, service providers, and benefit provisions.
Their responsibilities include protecting the financial resources of the Trust, monitoring investment performance, reviewing administration costs, and ensuring that decisions are consistent with the Trust Agreement.
Trustees also undertake professional development in trust governance, investment oversight, and employee benefits administration to support informed decision-making.
While the trustees oversee the Trust, its day-to-day administration and specialized functions are carried out with the assistance of professional service providers.
CATCA participates in the NCBAA, but it does not independently control the Trust or determine which benefits it provides. Similarly, CATCA has no authority over the separate Sun Life contract administered by NAV CANADA for pre-2010 retirees, although it can continue to advocate on behalf of its retired members.
Recognizing the Concerns of Pre-2010 Retirees
The absence of dental coverage for pre-2010 retirees is a genuine concern, and we recognize the frustration it has caused.
These members contributed to CATCA and the air traffic control profession throughout their careers. Many spent decades working alongside colleagues who now have access to benefits that they themselves do not receive.
The history of the Trust helps explain how these differences developed.
The 2009 Benefits Agreement fundamentally changed the funding arrangements for future retirees, transferring responsibility for their health-care premium subsidies from NAV CANADA to the Trust and providing significant additional funding to support those obligations.
The two retiree groups are also covered under separate Sun Life contracts. While the NCBAA Trust Fund oversees the benefits provided under the post-2009 plan, it has no authority over the NAV CANADA-administered plan covering pre-2010 retirees.
Since 2017, the Trust has continued supporting pre-2010 retirees through health-care premium subsidies beyond its original commitment, while its financial position has also permitted the introduction of dental benefits for post-2009 retirees.
These are important parts of the history, but they do not diminish the concerns of those who remain without dental coverage.
CATCA recognizes the importance of maintaining a strong relationship with its retired members and ensuring they have a clear understanding of the agreements and decisions that affect their benefits.
Our retirees helped build the profession and the Association we have today. Their concerns deserve to be heard and treated with respect.
Key milestones
2005
NCBAA Trust Fund established (September 1) following the NCJC Benefits Review agreement.
2007
Transfer agreement signed; initial $5.25 million received.
2009
NCJC Benefits Agreement adds $30.5 million and changes funding for future retirees.
2017
Original end date for premium subsidies to pre-2010 retirees — support continues.
2021
Benefits review completed: higher dispensing-fee reimbursement, $450,000 a year in added funding (2021–2023).
2023
Dental benefits introduced for eligible post-2009 retirees.
2025
Ellement becomes plan administrator (April 1).


